Both products turn home equity into spendable cash, and they run in opposite directions. A reverse mortgage is most often a HECM, which is open only at 62 and older, pays the owner and adds accruing interest to a balance settled when the home is sold. A HELOC is an open line you draw on and repay every month while the draw period runs.
How each works
A reverse mortgage pays equity out. The common form is a Home Equity Conversion Mortgage, a HECM, and the CFPB calls it a special home loan only for owners of 62 and older. The money can arrive as a lump sum, a monthly payout or a line of credit, and the CFPB says the line and the monthly payout can be combined. No monthly payment is required. Interest accrues and is added to the balance, so the debt rises instead of falling (Ramsey Solutions).
A HELOC is the other shape. It is an open-end line secured by the home: draw against a limit, repay, draw again (CFPB). Money comes by a special check or a card (CFPB brochure). The owner makes monthly payments (NCOA).
Both take a lien on the house and neither hands the deed to the lender. The line sits behind the first mortgage when there is one. The difference is direction. The reverse mortgage adds debt and removes the payment. The line keeps the balance in view and demands a payment while the draw period lasts.
Age and eligibility
A HECM starts with age. HUD's handbook says eligible borrowers are persons 62 years of age or older, and the CFPB states the same floor for the HECM. A younger owner cannot take one.
A HELOC has no federal age rule. The lender tests the file instead: the equity left after existing liens, the credit history, and income against the debts. One senior line copies the HECM floor, and Longbridge Financial's HELOC For Seniors programme requires a borrower to be 62 or older, though that is one lender's programme.
Equity is the first screen and the caps differ. Bank of America states an 85% limit, PenFed 85% except in Texas and on condominiums, and Chase 80% combined loan-to-value. Navy Federal states 95% of equity. In its cash-out refinancing guide, Ramsey Solutions says most lenders make you leave at least 20% of the value in the home.
Credit matters at the top of the market. US Bank's 7.05% as of November 2026 assumes a 730 FICO score and a 60% loan-to-value, and Navy Federal's 7.250% assumes 750 plus membership. Small needs meet minimum line sizes: Figure sets $15,000, Navy Federal $10,000, and PenFed $25,000 with a $4,000 minimum draw in Texas.
The 95% rule
The 95% rule is the HECM settlement rule for the estate. HUD Handbook 4235.1 REV-1, Chapter 1, says the borrower or the estate may pay "an amount equal to the lesser of the mortgage balance or the sales proceeds" when the property sells for at least 95% of its fair market value.
It applies after the mortgage becomes due and payable. It does not limit the initial loan and it does not force a sale. It is a floor on the payoff when the home sells at that price. The rule belongs to FHA-insured HECMs, not to proprietary reverse mortgages or HELOCs.
A HELOC has no matching rule. When the line's home is sold, the balance is repaid from the proceeds, and a shortfall stays with the estate.
Costs
The pricing runs opposite too. A HELOC has a variable rate, an index plus a margin, and any cap is set by the agreement (CFPB). The bank prime loan rate was 7.00% on (Federal Reserve). Posted APRs at six lenders in November 2026 ran from 5.740% at Bank of America to 8.37% at Chase, and each headline carries conditions: the Bank of America rate lasts six months and needs a $100,000 line, while Chase's sample assumes excellent credit and a 55% CLTV.
Fees are permitted and itemized. The CFPB lists application, origination, appraisal, title, closing, inactivity, annual, early-cancellation and conversion charges. No nonrefundable fee may be charged until three business days after the disclosures and brochure arrive. Bank of America advertises no closing costs on lines up to $1,000,000, Navy Federal advertises no closing costs and covers third-party costs, and PenFed pays most. Annual fees run $99 at PenFed and $75 at US Bank after the first year, and US Bank takes 1% of the balance, capped at $500, if the line closes within 30 months.
The HECM side prints its own charges. HUD puts the one-time initial mortgage insurance premium at 2% of the maximum claim amount and the monthly premium at an annual rate of 0.5% of the balance, with servicing capped at $30 a month on fixed-rate and annually adjustable loans (HUD handbook). The CFPB lists origination at $6,000 or less and names the initial premium among the upfront costs (CFPB). The senior line's own sheet names an origination fee and "costs" and prints no amount (Longbridge Financial), so the loan estimate remains the document to compare.
| Axis | HECM reverse mortgage | HELOC | Which fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum age | 62 (HUD; CFPB) | No federal rule; Longbridge's senior line sets 62 | Line, below 62 |
| 2026 national ceiling | $1,249,125 maximum claim amount for all areas, 2026 (HUD) | No national ceiling; lender equity and CLTV caps | Line, on a high-value home |
| Required monthly payment | None; taxes, insurance and upkeep stay with the owner | Required | HECM, on a fixed income |
| Monthly cost of $50,000 | None required | Bank of America, 5.740%: $239.17 interest-only; $548.60 amortized over 10 years | HECM if the payment must be zero; the line if it fits |
| PenFed, 7.0001%: $291.67 interest-only; $580.54 amortized over 10 years | |||
| US Bank, 7.05%: $293.75 interest-only; $581.83 amortized over 10 years | |||
| Figure, 7.25%: $302.08 interest-only; $587.01 amortized over 10 years | |||
| Navy Federal, 7.250%: $302.08 interest-only; $587.01 amortized over 10 years | |||
| Chase, 8.37%: $348.75 interest-only; $616.46 amortized over 10 years | |||
| Settlement at sale | Heirs may settle for the lesser of the balance or the proceeds at 95% of fair market value | Full balance repaid from the sale | HECM, for heirs |
| Maturity | Due when the mortgage becomes due and payable | Draw, then repayment; one senior line runs to 150 years after the borrower's date of birth | HECM for a lifetime hold; the line for a named end |
| Closing costs | Initial premium 2%; annual premium 0.5%; servicing capped at $30 a month (HUD) | Itemized fee list; $99 or $75 a year at two lenders | Neither is free; read both estimates |
HELOC payments calculated from the posted APRs of six lenders. Interest-only = $50,000 × APR ÷ 12; amortized = a 120-month payment at the same APR. HECM facts from HUD, the CFPB and NCOA; senior-line terms from Longbridge Financial. Checked by the editor.
Repayment and the heirs
A line runs on two clocks. The draw period keeps it open for spending, and repayment follows. Reg Z fixes no length for either but requires the lender to disclose both in the payment terms. The CFPB uses 10 years as a draw example and says repayment may run 10 or 15 years or end in a balloon. Posted terms differ: Bank of America describes 10 years of draw and 20 of repayment, Navy Federal 20 and 20, and Chase a three-year draw.
The HECM does not repay on a clock. The owner makes no required payment; property taxes, homeowners insurance and upkeep stay with the owner (NCOA). What ends it is the mortgage becoming due and payable, and then the home is sold or paid off.
That is where the heirs stand. The estate gets the 95% rule on a HECM: at a sale for at least 95% of fair market value it pays the lesser of the balance or the proceeds. On a HELOC the estate pays the line. A HECM balance at the end is higher than at the start because interest was added (Ramsey Solutions), and an interest-only HELOC also leaves principal untouched, so the real gap is the 95% floor against a full payoff.
Line freezes
A line can be cut off. Reg Z lets a lender freeze advances or reduce the limit only in listed cases, and a freeze must fit one of them. The grounds are default on a material obligation, a significant fall in the home's value, a material adverse change in the borrower's finances, government action that bars the contracted rate or drops the lien below 120% of the line, and a regulator's unsafe-and-unsound notice.
- A freeze stops new draws, and the balance already owed stays due.
- The rule does not quantify a "significant" decline in value.
- A frozen line can leave a renovation unfunded partway.
- A HECM has no line to freeze, but the taxes and insurance still have to be paid (NCOA).
The CFPB summarises the power: lenders generally may freeze or reduce the line if the home's value falls or the borrower's finances worsen.
Who each suits
The NCOA splits the uses, and the split is the test. It labels the line for ongoing or unexpected expenses and the reverse mortgage for supplementing retirement income. A HELOC fits a borrower with income to carry a payment: a new roof, a staged renovation, a medical bill with a date, or a card balance to clear while a paycheck still covers it.
A reverse mortgage fits the file where the payment itself is the problem. A 68-year-old on a fixed benefit who needs cash but cannot add a monthly bill is the case for it, and the age floor is already met. A HELOC fits a 60-year-old with wages because the door is open at any age, provided credit, income and equity clear.
The line also wins on a short horizon. It repays at sale with no settlement rule to navigate, while a HECM's upfront costs need time to earn back. On a large estate the HECM has a ceiling, and the line has only the lender's CLTV, so a high-value home with income may borrow more from a line.
Why do banks not recommend reverse mortgages?
The line is the easier sale, and the reason is structural. A HELOC earns interest and is repaid on a schedule, and it can be offered to any owner with equity and income. A HECM is closed to everyone under 62 by rule, so the pool is smaller from the first question.
The product also looks worse on a statement. Its balance rises with accrued interest instead of falling (Ramsey Solutions), and the fees are named. Ramsey Solutions lists reverse mortgages among mortgage options to avoid and calls one "a bad idea because you're putting a paid-for home at risk", adding that "the fees are horrible".
The case on the other side is the removed payment. A HECM requires no monthly payment and still leaves the owner the house, the taxes, the insurance and the upkeep (NCOA). A borrower who needs the payment gone is buying that feature, and the rising balance is its price.
The income and age questions for owners over 62 are worked through at HELOC for seniors. How the line accrues interest day by day is explained at how HELOC interest works. The full ledger of a line sits in HELOC pros and cons. Routes other than equity borrowing, including a home equity loan and a cash-out refinance, are compared at HELOC alternatives.
What does Dave Ramsey say about reverse mortgages?
Ramsey Solutions puts reverse mortgages among mortgage options to avoid. Its stated reason is the rising balance: with a normal mortgage the total falls, while with a reverse mortgage it rises as interest accrues. It also calls the product a bad idea because a paid-for home is put at risk and the fees are horrible. The removed monthly payment is the feature on the other side.