A HELOC keeps your first mortgage in place and adds a second lien you draw from as needed. A cash-out refinance replaces the first mortgage with a larger loan and hands you the difference once. The line prices only what you draw and costs less to open; the refinance puts one new rate on the whole balance and pays a lump sum. Which one fits depends on the rate on the first mortgage, the size and timing of the need, and how long you will keep the loan.
The two products
A HELOC is an open-end line of credit secured by home equity, and you can borrow against it repeatedly. It is a second mortgage, so the existing first mortgage stays and the line is repaid after it.
A cash-out refinance is a first mortgage. It retires the old loan at closing, writes a larger one, and pays the difference to you. The old rate disappears with the old loan, and the new rate applies to everything.
The shape decides the equity test. A line is capped by combined loan-to-value: Chase allows 80%, Bank of America 85%, and PenFed 85%, or 80% in Texas. Ramsey Solutions notes that most lenders make you leave at least 20% of the value in the home.
The payment count differs too. A line adds a second bill beside the mortgage. A refinance leaves one bill, on a larger balance, with the term reset to the day the new loan closes. A home equity loan is the fixed-sum second-lien shape between these two.
The rate trade
The rate lands on different amounts. A cash-out refinance applies its rate to every dollar of the first mortgage, including the part that was already cheap. A line applies its rate only to the draw. That is how a refinance can raise the cost of the whole house loan to reach a modest amount of cash.
The 2% rule is a common rule of thumb, and Heritage Family Credit Union calls it a guideline rather than a hard requirement. It says to refinance only when the new rate is at least two percentage points lower than the rate it replaces. No lender or regulation imposes it.
| Existing first mortgage | Refinance must beat | Intro line APR | Lowest regular line APR |
|---|---|---|---|
| 6.00% | 4.00% | 5.740% | 7.0001% |
| 7.00% | 5.00% | 5.740% | 7.0001% |
| 8.00% | 6.00% | 5.740% | 7.0001% |
Target = existing rate minus two points: 6.00% − 2.00 = 4.00%. The line columns are Bank of America's 5.740% for six months on a $100,000 line and PenFed's 7.0001%. Checked by the editor.
At a 6.00% mortgage, the intro line is below the old rate and the regular line above it, so any rise reaches only the drawn amount. No refinance above 4.00% clears the rule for a lump sum. At 8.00%, the lowest regular line is already under the old rate, and a refinance under 6.00% is the clean win.
| Term | Cash-out refinance | HELOC |
|---|---|---|
| What is repriced | The whole first mortgage. | Only the drawn balance. |
| Payout | One sum at closing. | As needed during the draw. |
| Equity kept | At least 20% of value. | Combined loan-to-value caps of 80% to 85%. |
| Fees | Full first-mortgage closing costs. | Listed fees, refundable if a term changes. |
| Tax | Acquisition debt up to $750,000. | The same use test. |
Equity figure from Ramsey Solutions; line caps from Chase, Bank of America and PenFed. Checked by the editor, variant D.
Closing costs
The two fee bills differ in kind. A refinance pays for a new first mortgage: application, appraisal, title, underwriting and recording on the entire new loan. The borrower recovers that outlay only through a lower rate, over enough years, and there is no matching refund rule.
A line has a fee menu instead: application, origination, appraisal, title and closing, inactivity, annual, early cancellation and conversion. Federal rules add timing. No nonrefundable fee can be charged until three business days after the disclosures and brochure arrive, and every fee must be refunded if a disclosed term changes — other than an index-driven rate change — and the borrower walks away. A line also carries a cancellation right until midnight of the third business day.
Posted terms vary widely. Bank of America advertises no closing costs on lines up to $1,000,000, and Navy Federal advertises none. US Bank charges no application or closing costs but a $75 annual fee after the first year and a 1% early-closure fee, capped at $500, inside 30 months. PenFed pays most costs and charges $99 a year. Figure advertises a one-time origination fee of up to 4.99% of the initial draw.
The waivers are not total. Taxes, recording and prepaid interest can still fall on the borrower. The itemised list sits in the closing-cost guide.
Payment math
Compare one balance, and note what the refinance figure leaves out. The table puts $50,000 at 7.00%, near the prime rate, into four shapes. A cash-out refinance has no $50,000 payment of its own; that row is the slice a new 30-year first mortgage adds, not the whole bill.
| Shape | Monthly payment | Balance after 10 years | Interest paid in 10 years |
|---|---|---|---|
| HELOC, interest only | $291.67 | $50,000 | $35,000 |
| Cash-out refinance slice, 30 years | $332.65 | $42,906 | $32,824 |
| HELOC, 20-year repayment | $387.65 | $33,387 | $29,905 |
| HELOC, 10-year repayment | $580.54 | $0 | $19,665 |
Interest only is $50,000 × 7.00% ÷ 12 = $291.67. Amortizing rows spread the same balance over 120, 240 or 360 payments. Calculated from the prime rate of 7.00% on ; checked by the editor.
Interest-only is the lowest bill and the weakest amortizer: after 10 years the balance is still $50,000. The 30-year refinance slice is next, and it leaves $42,906 owed. A 20-year line repays $387.65 a month and leaves $33,387. A 10-year repayment clears the balance at $580.54.
The refinance row is cheap monthly only because the term is long. Set against a 30-year mortgage that restarts the clock, the figure is a monthly cost, not a total cost.
- Interest-only payments leave the whole balance in place.
- A variable line can reprice; the table holds 7.00% still.
- The refinance slice resets the first mortgage term, so lifetime interest can rise even when the monthly bill falls.
- Closing costs sit outside every figure.
When each wins
A cash-out refinance wins on one condition: the existing first mortgage is well above the rate a new first mortgage would carry. Then the refinance lowers the cost of the balance already owed and funds the cash need in one move. It fits a large, one-time sum and a borrower who stays past the break-even.
A HELOC wins when the existing mortgage is already lower than today's line rates. The cheap first loan stays, and only the draw carries the higher price. It fits staged work, an uncertain total and a short horizon, and it lets the borrower draw and repay as the need changes.
Neither fits a small, short need. The CFPB lists a personal line of credit and a credit card beside the home equity options, and both avoid a new lien. How each option compares is set out in the alternatives guide.
Tax follows use, not product. Interest is deductible on either only when the money buys, builds or substantially improves the home, and only on the first $750,000 of acquisition debt. Card payoff and tuition fail the test.
Ramsey Solutions is stricter than the rule. It says to refinance only for a much shorter term or a much lower rate, and it notes that most lenders make a borrower leave at least 20% of value.
- A second bill is harder to carry if income is uneven.
- Less than 20% equity can block a cash-out or shrink a line.
- A sale inside the break-even can wipe out a refinance saving.
- A variable line payment can rise without warning.
The Texas position
Texas writes its home equity rules into the constitution, and they bind a cash-out refinance as much as a line. Four rules matter before either product.
- The cap is 80% of fair market value, counting all other lien balances.
- No closing before the 12th day after the later of the application or the required notice.
- No new home equity loan until the first anniversary of the previous one's closing.
- The lien may be foreclosed only by court order.
Lender terms tighten inside those rules. PenFed drops its combined loan-to-value cap to 80% in Texas and sets a $4,000 minimum draw. Navy Federal's HELOC is not available there. Chase's line is likewise unavailable in Texas.
The three-day cancellation right still applies to the line. A Texas borrowing clears the same equity and income tests as anywhere else. Current APRs show what a line would cost once it clears them.
What does Dave Ramsey say about cash-out refinance?
Ramsey Solutions says to refinance only if it means a much shorter loan term or a much lower rate. It also says most lenders will make you leave at least 20% of your home's value in place. The house view prefers saved cash and treats home debt as a risk to clear.
A fixed-sum second lien is explained at HELOC vs home equity loan, and the alternatives cover the wider set. Closing costs itemise the fees on both sides.