A personal loan is an unsecured installment loan: one fixed sum, one fixed payment, no lien. A HELOC is a revolving line secured by your equity, and it prices lower because the house stands behind it. The line wins when the job is large, staged, or long, and when the interest may be deductible. The loan wins when the job is small and fast and you want to leave the deed alone.
The trade
You are trading price for security. A HELOC is "a line of credit, like a credit card, except you are borrowing against the equity of your home" (CFPB explainer), and the home is the collateral (CFPB brochure). A personal loan is unsecured. There is no appraisal, no lien and no second mortgage, so the lender holds only your promise and your credit record.
That single difference sets every other row. The line can be cheaper and larger because the lender has a house to take. The loan costs more and stays smaller because the lender has only you. Neither is free: one prices the risk, the other carries it.
Rates
The line's price follows an index. HELOC rates are typically variable, an index plus a margin (CFPB brochure), and Reg Z lets a lender move the APR only with a public index outside its control (12 CFR 1026.40(f)(1)). The bank prime rate was 7.00% on (Federal Reserve H.15). Posted APRs ran from a 5.740% six-month intro at Bank of America to 11.10% at US Bank as of . Chase's 8.37% sits mid-range, and Bank of America prints 8.650% after the intro. A personal loan's rate is usually fixed for the term, though adjustable versions exist (CFPB).
| Product | Rate | Monthly on $50,000 | Monthly on $100,000 | Security | Fees |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HELOC, lowest posted rate, six-month intro | 5.740% | $239.17 interest-only | $478.33 interest-only | Home | No closing costs at Bank of America, up to a $1M line |
| HELOC, highest posted rate, variable sample | 11.10% | $462.50 interest-only | $925.00 interest-only | Home | Full fee menu may apply |
| HELOC, amortising over 10 years | 5.740%–11.10% | $548.60–$691.58 | $1,097.19–$1,383.17 | Home | As above |
| Personal loan, 24-month average | 11.90% average | Quoted with the offer | Quoted with the offer | None | Origination may apply |
Interest-only is balance × APR ÷ 12, so $50,000 at 5.740% = $239.17 and $100,000 at 11.10% = $925.00. The amortising rows spread the balance over 120 payments at the same APRs. Calculated from the posted APRs of six lenders. Checked by the editor.
A personal loan often carries an origination fee, listed with the others before you agree (CFPB). The line has a longer menu: application, appraisal, title, closing, inactivity, annual, early cancellation and conversion fees (CFPB). Federal rules delay the nonrefundable ones. No such fee may be charged until three business days after you receive the disclosures and brochure (12 CFR 1026.40(h)), and fees must be refunded if a disclosed term changes and you walk away (12 CFR 1026.40(g)). Competition trims it: Bank of America advertises no closing costs on lines up to $1,000,000, Navy Federal advertises none, US Bank charges none, and PenFed pays most. Annual fees remain at PenFed ($99) and US Bank ($75 after year one).
Limits
The line's ceiling is your equity, less the first mortgage, then a lender cap. Chase allows 80% combined loan-to-value, Bank of America 85% and PenFed 85% outside Texas; Navy Federal lends up to 95% of equity. Minimums also exist: Figure $15,000, Navy Federal $10,000 and PenFed $25,000.
A personal loan is sized to income and credit, so the equity arithmetic never enters. That cuts both ways: no appraisal and no lien, but a lower ceiling set by the lender.
Credit decides the best price on both. Navy Federal's 7.250% needs membership and a 750 FICO score. US Bank's 7.05% needs a $50,000 line, 60% LTV, a 730 score and autopay. Bank of America's 5.740% is a six-month intro that assumes a $100,000 line. PenFed's 7.0001% requires membership.
Speed
The line is slow by design. The house must be appraised, the lien recorded and the closing held. Then the rescission clock runs: the right lasts until midnight of the third business day after the last triggering event (12 CFR 1026.15(a)(4)). It applies when the plan opens, on an extension, an added security interest or a credit-limit increase (12 CFR 1026.15(a)(1)), not on each draw (12 CFR 1026.15(a)(2)). The CFPB brochure tells consumers they may cancel within three days by written notice and get their fees back.
The fee likewise waits until three business days after the disclosures (12 CFR 1026.40(h)). A personal loan skips the appraisal and the lien, so approval can turn into cash in days, with no rescission right.
Tax treatment
Only the secured product can generate deductible interest. HELOC interest is deductible only when the proceeds buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures it, and only if you itemize (IRS Publication 936). The cap is the first $750,000 of acquisition debt, or $375,000 on a separate married return (26 U.S.C. §163(h)(3)(F)(i)(II)).
The use test is strict. Paying off cards fails it (IRS FAQ); a renovation passes. A personal loan is unsecured, so its interest does not meet the same test and is generally not deductible. The deduction is the line's one unambiguous advantage in the tax code.
Risk
The line puts the house in play; the loan does not. A default on a HELOC can cost the home, because the home is the collateral (CFPB brochure). The lender can also freeze advances or cut the limit on a default, a significant fall in value or a material change in finances (12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)). Even a paid-up borrower is exposed at the end: repayment begins when the draw ends, and the lender may schedule 10 or 15 years or demand a balloon (CFPB brochure).
- The home secures the line, so a default can put it at risk.
- The lender may freeze or reduce the line when value or finances worsen.
- The payment rises when the draw ends, and a balloon can make the whole balance due.
- A personal loan never puts the house at risk, but a missed payment still damages credit.
A personal loan's worst case is a fixed payment you cannot make: late fees, credit damage and collections, then a judgment only after a lawsuit. Ramsey Solutions goes further and calls a HELOC "one of the biggest financial traps you can fall into", citing the balance falling due at sale or term end and the freeze power.
When each wins
Choose the line for a cost that arrives in stages or is not yet priced: a renovation billed by room, tuition split across terms, a reserve against a layoff, or a $50,000 renovation. Choose it when the money will buy or improve the home and you itemize, so the interest is deductible.
Choose the loan for a small, one-off, urgent bill with a known figure: a car repair, a medical balance, a move. Choose it when you have little equity, no appetite for an appraisal, or want the debt off the deed. The fixed payment also suits a budget that cannot absorb a variable rate.
Is it better to get a home equity line of credit or a personal loan?
Better for a large, staged, deductible need is the HELOC. Better for a small, fast, one-off need is the personal loan. The line is cheaper because it is secured; the loan is safer because it is not.
A line used to clear card balances has its own arithmetic at HELOC for debt consolidation. The wider field, including a card and a home equity loan, sits at HELOC alternatives. Check current APRs at HELOC rates and run your own balance at the HELOC calculator.