A mortgage is the first loan on a home, taken to buy or refinance it, while a HELOC is a revolving line that sits behind that loan and borrows against the equity. The mortgage is repaid on one schedule from the first payment. The line opens a draw period and switches to repayment later. It prices off a variable rate. A purchase or refinance needs the mortgage; staged or uncertain costs fit the line.
Definitions
A mortgage is the loan that buys the home or replaces the one that did, and it holds first position. Every second lien, a HELOC included, sits behind it.
A HELOC is "a line of credit, like a credit card, except you are borrowing against the equity of your home" (CFPB explainer). It is open-end credit: you borrow, spend and repay as you go, and credit returns as the balance falls (CFPB).
An ordinary HELOC is a second mortgage, while the mortgage already holds the property. That position, not the rate, sets who is paid first on a sale or a default.
The difference table
The two do different jobs, as the axes show.
| Axis | First mortgage | HELOC | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Position | First lien, paid first | Second lien behind the mortgage | Mortgage, on a sale |
| Shape | One advance | Revolving line, redrawn as you repay | Each fits its job |
| Rate | Priced once at closing, fixed or adjustable | Typically variable, an index plus a margin | Mortgage, for a known payment |
| Term | Full loan term, principal from payment one | Draw then repayment, no length fixed by rule | Mortgage, for a forced payoff |
| Access | Paid once, to the seller or the old lender | Drawn as needed in the draw period | HELOC, for staged costs |
| Tax test | Acquisition debt in ordinary use | Only when proceeds buy, build or improve | Mortgage, in ordinary use |
No axis wins outright. The mortgage owns the purchase, first position and a fixed payment; the line owns timing and reuse.
Rates
A mortgage is priced at closing. A line is an index plus a margin, and the CFPB says HELOC rates are typically variable. Regulation lets the APR move only with a public index outside the creditor's control, and any rate-change limit must be disclosed with the maximum APR. The regulation sets no ceiling; the contract does.
| Product | Rate | Term | Fees | Monthly payment on $100,000 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HELOC | Variable, index plus margin; advertised APRs of 5.740% for six months, 8.650% after | Draw of 3 to 20 years, then a repayment period | Fee menu with no federal cap; no nonrefundable fee until three business days after the disclosures | $583.33 interest-only at 7.00%; $1,161.08 amortized over 10 years |
| Mortgage | Set at closing, fixed or adjustable | Full term, principal from the first payment | Origination and closing costs paid at the start | Set by the rate and term at closing |
Interest-only is $100,000 × 7.00% ÷ 12 = $583.33; the other line spreads the same balance over 120 payments. Prime rate on from the Federal Reserve's bank prime series. Checked by the editor.
Advertised HELOC APRs run from 5.740% at Bank of America for six months to 8.650% on the same page after that; Chase's sample for one ZIP on was 8.37%. PenFed's 7.0001% is the lowest without an intro. Bank of America's 5.740% lasts six months, Navy Federal's 7.25% needs a 750 FICO and membership, and US Bank's 7.05% needs a $50,000 line, a 60% LTV and autopay. The bank prime loan rate was 7.00% on . A mortgage rate is quoted per borrower and lock, with no single posted figure.
Term and repayment
A mortgage has one clock. The sum is advanced at closing and amortizes at once, so the balance falls from the start. A line has two clocks. Regulation does not fix either length; the creditor must disclose the draw period and any repayment period.
The draw is the time the line is open for spending, with money pulled by a special check or card (CFPB brochure). The agency uses 10 years as an example, not a limit. Lenders print their own: Bank of America describes 10 years of draw and 20 of repayment, Navy Federal 20 and 20, and Chase a three-year draw.
At the end of the draw the repayment period begins. The lender may spread the balance over 10 or 15 years or demand a balloon, and in some cases the whole sum is due as soon as repayment starts (CFPB). A mortgage avoids that cliff because repayment began with the first payment.
Use cases
The mortgage is the instrument for the purchase itself, and for a refinance that replaces the existing first loan. A line is the instrument for cash after the purchase: a renovation billed in stages, tuition across several terms, or a reserve against a layoff. The CFPB lists a home equity loan, a cash-out refinance, a personal line and a credit card as alternatives.
Tax treatment separates two uses. Money spent on the home can qualify; money for personal items usually does not. A renovation passes that test, a credit-card payoff or a holiday does not.
Qualification
A first mortgage is underwritten against the price, down payment, income and credit. A HELOC is underwritten against what is left: value minus the mortgage, under a combined loan-to-value cap.
- Chase caps CLTV at 80%; Bank of America generally at 85%; PenFed at 85% CLTV, or 80% in Texas and on condos.
- Navy Federal advertises up to 95% of equity, and its best rate needs a 750 FICO.
- Ramsey Solutions puts typical approval around 80% of equity, and its cash-out refinance guide says most lenders make you leave at least 20% in the home.
- A line also has a floor: Figure's minimum loan is $15,000, Navy Federal's $10,000, and PenFed's $25,000.
Because the first mortgage counts in CLTV, every dollar of it reduces the line, and a large mortgage can leave no equity to lend against.
Costs
Both products carry closing costs, and the mortgage's are paid or financed at the start. The line's fees follow a published menu: application, closing, inactivity, annual or membership, early cancellation and conversion (CFPB). Regulation sets a timing rule, not a cap: no nonrefundable fee may be taken until three business days after the disclosures and brochure arrive, and fees are refunded if a disclosed term changes and you walk away.
Some lenders waive the line's closing costs. Bank of America advertises none on lines up to $1,000,000; Navy Federal advertises none; PenFed pays most; US Bank charges no application fee or closing cost but takes 1%, up to $500, if the line closes within 30 months. Annual fees remain at some lenders: PenFed $99, US Bank $75 after the first year, while Bank of America advertises none.
Tax treatment
A mortgage is acquisition debt when the money buys, builds or substantially improves the home, and interest on the first $750,000 of that debt is deductible by itemizers, or $375,000 on a separate married return (26 U.S.C. §163(h)(3)(F); IRS Publication 936). A line gets no separate allowance: its interest is deductible only when the funds do the same job, within that shared ceiling.
So a HELOC drawn for a kitchen passes and a HELOC drawn to pay credit cards fails, though both are secured by the house. The lender reports the interest on Form 1098 either way, and the form does not decide the deduction.
Is a HELOC a trap?
Ramsey Solutions calls a HELOC "one of the biggest financial traps you can fall into" and prefers saved cash. Its reasons are that the home is collateral, the balance can fall due at term's end or on a sale, and the lender can freeze the line. The lender may stop advances or cut the limit when the home's value falls significantly or the borrower's finances change materially.
The trap case bites hardest when the line replaces the mortgage. A first mortgage amortizes on a fixed clock; a line can sit interest-only through the draw, so the purchase balance can still be there years later. Behind a mortgage, the feature is easier to manage because the first loan forces principal down.
How is a $50,000 home equity loan different from a $50,000 home equity line of credit?
How is a $50,000 home equity loan different from a $50,000 home equity line of credit?
At one balance and one rate the difference is principal. A $50,000 home equity loan at 7.00% costs $580.54 a month and clears in 10 years. A $50,000 line at the same rate costs $291.67 interest-only and still owes $50,000 after 10 years. Amortize the line and it matches the loan; keep it interest-only and the gap is the whole balance.
What are the disadvantages of a HELOC?
What are the disadvantages of a HELOC?
- The rate is typically variable and can rise with the index.
- The payment jumps when the draw ends, and a balloon can make the whole balance due.
- The fee menu includes annual, inactivity and early-cancellation charges; PenFed charges $99 a year.
- The lender can freeze advances or cut the limit after a value drop or a financial setback.
- The home secures the line, so a default can cost the house.
- Credit returns as you repay, which makes re-borrowing easy.
The second-lien version of this comparison is at HELOC vs second mortgage. A line that takes first position and replaces the mortgage is covered at first-lien HELOC. If the choice is between a line and a new first loan, see HELOC vs cash-out refinance, and the full ledger is at HELOC pros and cons.