The two products pull the same equity out of the same house in opposite shapes. A home equity line of credit is an open line: you draw, repay, and draw again during a draw period, then reach a repayment period. A home equity loan is one advance, repaid on a schedule from the first payment. The line fits a cost that arrives in stages. The loan fits a single bill you can name and want gone on a timetable.
Definitions
A home equity loan is "a specific amount of money borrowed against the equity of your home". A HELOC is "a line of credit, like a credit card, except you are borrowing against the equity of your home" (CFPB explainer).
A line is open-end credit secured by the home, and credit returns as the balance falls (CFPB). Both sit behind the first mortgage.
The one structural difference
One product is a tap; the other is a bucket. A HELOC is a revolving line that stays open for a set draw period, and every repayment restores the credit. A home equity loan is a single advance. Most other differences follow from that split.
| Axis | HELOC | Home equity loan | Which wins |
|---|---|---|---|
| Structure | Revolving line, redrawn as you repay | One lump sum | The difference itself |
| Rate | Typically variable | Can be fixed or adjustable | Loan, for a known payment |
| Access | Draw as needed in the draw period | Money arrives once | Line, for staged timing |
| Repayment | Can be interest-only in the draw | Principal from the first payment | Loan, for a forced payoff |
| Tax test | Proceeds must buy, build or improve | Proceeds must buy, build or improve | Tie |
Rates and closing costs
A line prices off an index plus a margin (CFPB brochure), and Reg Z lets the lender move the APR only with a public index outside its control (12 CFR 1026.40(f)(1)). The bank prime loan rate was 7.00% on (Federal Reserve H.15). The CFPB says HELOC rates are typically variable.
Setting intro rates aside, posted APRs on lender pages run from 6.70% at US Bank to 8.650% at Bank of America. Bank of America's 5.740% lasts six months and needs a $100,000 line. Navy Federal's 7.25% needs membership and a 750 FICO; US Bank's 7.05% needs a $50,000 line and a 60% LTV. A home equity loan may carry a fixed or adjustable rate.
Fees exist on both. The CFPB lists the line's: application, closing, inactivity, annual, early cancellation and conversion. No nonrefundable fee may be charged until three business days after you receive the disclosures and brochure (12 CFR 1026.40(h)); if a term changes and you walk away, fees are refunded (12 CFR 1026.40(g)). Some lenders waive closing costs: Bank of America and Navy Federal advertise none, PenFed pays most, US Bank none. Annual fees remain: PenFed $99, US Bank $75 after year one.
Repayment
A line has two clocks. The draw period is the time the line is open for spending, with money pulled by a special check or card (CFPB brochure). Reg Z fixes no length; the lender must disclose it (12 CFR 1026.40(d)(5)(i)), and the CFPB uses 10 years as an example. Terms differ: Bank of America describes 10 years of draw and 20 of repayment, Navy Federal 20 and 20, US Bank 10 and 20, Chase a three-year draw.
At the end, repayment begins. The lender may schedule the balance over 10 or 15 years or demand a balloon (CFPB brochure), or the whole sum can come due at once. A loan has no draw: the sum arrives at closing and amortizes at once.
| Structure | Rate | Monthly payment | Interest over 10 years | Balance after 10 years |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HELOC, interest-only draw | 7.00% | $292 | $35,000 | $50,000 |
| HELOC, interest-only at Chase's published APR | 8.37% | $349 | $41,850 | $50,000 |
| HELOC, amortizing | 7.00% | $581 | $19,665 | $0 |
| Home equity loan, amortizing | 7.00% | $581 | $19,665 | $0 |
Interest-only = $50,000 × 7.00% ÷ 12. Amortizing = $50,000 at 7.00% over 120 months. Both priced at the prime rate on , with the 8.37% row at Chase's published variable APR. Checked 16 November 2026 by the editor.
Tax treatment
The test follows the use of the money, not the product name. Interest on either product is deductible only when the proceeds buy, build or substantially improve the securing home, and only for itemizers (IRS Publication 936). The ceiling is the first $750,000 of acquisition debt, or $375,000 on a separate married return (26 U.S.C. §163(h)(3)(F)). Credit-card payoff fails the test (IRS FAQ).
Collateral and foreclosure
The house secures both, and the first mortgage keeps priority, so a default can reach either one.
- The line and the loan are second mortgages, so a sale or refinance must clear both.
- The lender may freeze advances or cut the limit on a default, a significant fall in value, or a material change in finances (12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)(vi)).
- At the term's end, or on sale, the balance is due (Ramsey Solutions).
- The loan amortizes to zero; an interest-only line can leave the full balance for the end.
Which use fits which product
A known bill with a known deadline fits the loan: one $50,000 advance for a signed contract, repaid over 10 years, with no draw to manage. A staged or uncertain cost fits the line: a renovation billed room by room, tuition across terms, or a reserve against job loss. Home improvements clear the tax test (IRS Publication 936); tuition and debt consolidation are not named in the FAQ.
Eligibility decides the rest. Value minus the first mortgage is equity, and most borrowers are approved around 80% of it (Ramsey Solutions), leaving about 20% of the equity unused. Caps vary: Chase 80% CLTV, Bank of America 85%, PenFed 85%, Navy Federal up to 95% of equity. Navy Federal's best rate also needs a 750 FICO.
How is a $50,000 home equity loan different from a $50,000 home equity line of credit?
At one balance and rate, the gap is principal. A $50,000 loan at 7.00% costs $581 a month and clears in 10 years. A line at interest-only costs $292 and still owes $50,000. Amortize the line and it matches the loan, so the difference is the interest-only choice.
What are the disadvantages of having a HELOC?
- The rate is typically variable, an index plus a margin.
- The payment can jump when the draw ends, and a balloon can make the whole balance due.
- Annual, inactivity and early-cancellation fees: PenFed $99 a year, US Bank $75 after year one.
- The lender can freeze the line on default, a value drop or a change in finances.
- The home is collateral, and the balance is called at term end or on sale.
Ramsey Solutions calls a HELOC "one of the biggest financial traps you can fall into" and prefers saved cash. Its reasons are the collateral, the balance due at term end or on sale, and the freeze power.
The refinance route is compared at heloc vs cash out refinance if the first mortgage is also in play. HELOC rates shows what either product costs now. The second-mortgage framing sits at HELOC vs second mortgage. Weigh the full ledger at HELOC pros and cons. Run your own balance at the HELOC calculator.