Skip to content
How a HELOC Works

Posted rates and terms from six lenders · checked Nov 2026 · Methodology

HELOC vs Second Mortgage

Short answerA HELOC is a second mortgage with a revolver attached: you draw, repay and draw again during a draw period. A closed-end second mortgage, usually a home equity loan, hands over one fixed sum. Both sit behind the first mortgage and put the same house at risk. The line fits staged costs; the lump sum fits one known bill.

A HELOC is a second mortgage with a revolver attached: you draw, repay and draw again during a draw period. A closed-end second mortgage, usually a home equity loan, hands over one fixed sum. Both sit behind the first mortgage and put the same house at risk. The line fits a cost that arrives in stages. The loan fits one bill you can name and want gone on a timetable.

What a second mortgage is

"Second mortgage" names a position, not a product. It is any loan or line secured by a home that already carries a first mortgage. The two consumer forms are the home equity loan and the home equity line of credit. A home equity loan is "a specific amount of money borrowed against the equity of your home", and a HELOC is "a line of credit, like a credit card, except you are borrowing against the equity of your home" (CFPB explainer). Both are second mortgages.

A line is open-end credit secured by the home, so credit returns as the balance falls (CFPB). The loan is closed-end: the money is advanced once and the schedule starts. Neither is a first mortgage, and neither replaces the loan already on the house.

The two shapes

Strip away the marketing and one difference remains: a line can be redrawn, a lump sum cannot. Every cost, payment and risk difference in this comparison follows from that split.

The same equity in two shapes
AxisHELOCSecond-mortgage loanVerdict
What it isOpen-end line, borrowed repeatedlyClosed-end lump sum, one advanceLine for access, loan for discipline
Money arrivesAs you draw during the draw periodOnce, at closingLine for staged bills
RateTypically variable, index plus a marginPriced once for the termLoan when the payment must be known
PaymentCan be interest-only in the drawPrincipal from the first monthLoan forces the balance down
Best useA cost that arrives in stagesA single signed billThe other product is wrong here

The line is a form of open credit, and the CFPB says money is pulled with special checks or a card (CFPB brochure). That suits a renovation billed room by room or tuition due each term. It is a poor fit for a single contract where a known payment is the point. The lump sum gives no redraw, so a partial prepayment cannot be taken back.

Rates and fees

Both products price off the same benchmark, but only the line follows it between closings. The bank prime loan rate was 7.00% on (Federal Reserve H.15). A line is typically an index plus a margin, and Reg Z lets the lender move the APR only with a public index outside its control (12 CFR 1026.40(f)(1)).

Posted line APRs run from 5.740% at Bank of America to 11.10% at US Bank. The Bank of America figure is a special introductory variable APR for six months and needs a $100,000 line. US Bank's posted range runs from 6.70% to 11.10% as of . Chase's 8.37% is a sample for one ZIP code, dated . Figure's lowest advertised rate is 7.25% as of . Navy Federal's as-low-as 7.250% needs membership and a 750 FICO. US Bank's 7.05% requires a $50,000 line, 60% LTV and a 730 FICO, and PenFed's 7.0001% needs membership.

Fees are where the line can cost more than the headline. The CFPB lists application, origination and closing, inactivity, annual, early-cancellation and conversion fees. No nonrefundable fee may be charged until three business days after you receive the disclosures and brochure (12 CFR 1026.40(h)), and fees are refunded if a disclosed term changes and you walk away (12 CFR 1026.40(g)). Posted costs vary by lender:

Posted line costs at four lenders
LenderClosing costsAnnual feeEarly closure
Bank of AmericaNone on lines up to $1,000,000None$450 within 36 months
Navy FederalNoneNoneNot stated
US BankNone$75 after year one1%, capped at $500, within 30 months
PenFedPays most$99Not stated

Bank of America also advertises no application fee and no annual fee (Bank of America's posted terms), and Navy Federal no application, origination, annual or inactivity fee. A closed-end loan carries its own closing costs, but its rate is set once and does not track the index.

Repayment

A line has two clocks. The draw period is when the line is open for spending (CFPB brochure). Reg Z fixes no length and requires the lender to disclose it (12 CFR 1026.40(d)(5)(i)), and the CFPB uses 10 years as an example. Posted draws differ: Bank of America describes usually 10 years, US Bank 10 on its fixed-rate page, PenFed 10, Navy Federal 20, and Chase a three-year draw.

At the end, a repayment period begins. The lender may schedule the balance over 10 or 15 years or demand a balloon (CFPB brochure); the CFPB also says 20 years is common and that the full balance can come due at once. A closed-end loan has no draw and amortizes from the first payment.

One $50,000 balance: interest-only line against a 10-year lump-sum loan
PricingLine, interest-only monthLoan, 10-year monthLoan interest over 10 yearsLine balance after 10 years
Lowest posted APR, 5.740% (Bank of America, first six months)$239.17$548.60$15,831.61$50,000
Prime rate, 7.00% on $291.67$580.54$19,665.09$50,000
Highest posted APR, 11.10% (US Bank, top of range)$462.50$691.58$32,990.01$50,000
Line amortized like the loan, at 7.00%$580.54$580.54$19,665.09$0

Line payment = $50,000 × rate ÷ 12. Loan and amortized line = $50,000 at the same rate over 120 months. Prime from the Federal Reserve. Checked by the editor.

The gap is principal. At the prime rate the line costs $291.67 a month against $580.54 for the loan, but the line still owes $50,000 after a decade. The lower payment is not free money; it is interest with no amortization. Pay interest-only only while the principal has another exit.

Qualification

Both products are second liens, so the lender prices the position and the borrower the same way. Equity is the first test. Bank of America generally lends to 85% of value, Chase caps at 80%, Figure's calculator assumes 80%, and PenFed caps combined loan-to-value at 85%, or 80% in Texas and on condos. Navy Federal advertises up to 95% of equity. Ramsey Solutions puts the working rule lower, saying most borrowers are approved for around 80% of their equity.

Credit is written into the price. Navy Federal's as-low-as 7.250% assumes a 750 FICO; US Bank's 7.05% assumes a 730 and a 60% LTV. Expect an appraisal for either shape. A line must also clear the lender's minimum loan amount: Figure sets $15,000, Navy Federal $10,000, PenFed $25,000.

Most lenders will not let you cash out all of your equity. "Most lenders won't let you cash out all of your home equity—you'll probably have to leave at least 20% in your home" (Ramsey Solutions' cash-out refinancing guide). The rule applies to both shapes, because the house secures the first mortgage and the new second loan at once.

When a second mortgage is right

A second mortgage is right when the equity is spare, the use is defined and the payment fits after the first mortgage. One known bill with a signed price fits the loan: a $50,000 kitchen contract repaid on a fixed 10-year schedule. A cost that arrives in stages fits the line: room-by-room work, tuition across terms, or a reserve that may never be drawn.

Tax treatment follows the use, not the product name. Interest is deductible only when the proceeds buy, build or substantially improve the home that secures the loan, and only for itemizers (IRS Publication 936). A credit-card payoff fails that test (IRS FAQ). The ceiling is the first $750,000 of acquisition debt, or $375,000 on a separate married return (26 U.S.C. §163(h)(3)(F)).

The risks are the same on both sides:

  • The home is collateral, and the second lien sits behind the first.
  • A variable line can raise the payment; a fixed loan cannot.
  • The lender may freeze the line on a default, a significant fall in value or a material change in finances (12 CFR 1026.40(f)(3)(vi)(A)–(C)).
  • At the end of the draw, the balance can spread over 10 or 15 years or come due as a balloon (CFPB brochure).
  • Annual fees and an early-closure fee can outlast the reason you borrowed.

Ramsey Solutions calls a HELOC "one of the biggest financial traps you can fall into" and prefers saved cash. Its reasons are the house as collateral, the balance called at term end or on sale, and the freeze power.

How is a $50,000 home equity loan different from a $50,000 home equity line of credit?

At the same $50,000 and the same 7.00% rate, the loan costs $580.54 a month, clears in 10 years and pays $19,665.09 in interest. The line at interest-only costs $291.67, pays $35,000 in interest and still owes $50,000. Amortize the line and the two match. The higher monthly payment is the principal that the line leaves untouched.

Is a 2nd mortgage a good idea?

A second mortgage is a good idea when the equity is spare, the rate is below the cost of the alternative and the payment survives a bad month. It is a poor idea when a line funds a standing deficit, because the draw period ends and the repayment starts whether the budget has recovered or not.

Named situations settle it. A fixed-rate loan against a signed renovation that raises the home's value is the cleanest case; the interest can clear the tax test and the payment falls to zero at term. A HELOC used to consolidate credit cards is cheaper on paper than the cards, but the balances can refill and the line remains a variable second lien on the house. Ramsey's verdict is blunt: a HELOC is "one of the biggest financial traps you can fall into" (Ramsey Solutions).

Compare the loan shape at HELOC vs home equity loan, which covers the loan that is itself a second mortgage. The first-lien comparison sits at HELOC vs mortgage. Weigh the full ledger at HELOC pros and cons. Run your own balance at the HELOC calculator.

is a second mortgage a good idea?

It can be, if you have spare equity, a defined use and a payment that fits. Both products put the house behind the debt, and a line adds a variable rate and a freeze risk. Take the lump sum for a known bill, the line for staged costs, and leave cash for the months the payment is due.

Sources

Read next

How to cite How a HELOC Works. "HELOC vs Second Mortgage." Updated November 16, 2026. https://howdoesahelocwork.com/heloc-vs-second-mortgage/